Quote:
Is there any reason why the accents when the other way? Was it a concious decision to be different or just developed that way?
Scottish Gaelic was written in Irish until the 16th-17th centuries, although the pronunciation, vocabulary, and some of the grammar had already diverged from Irish. Once the link to Gaelic Ireland was broken, Scottish Gaelic gradually acquired its own writing system. As it was developing (a process not yet entirely complete -- there are still competing spellings for a number of words), it used both grave and acute accents, but to represent different sounds. There was no official body in charge of Gaelic until the last few decades, though, and that made the process of change somewhat chaotic. Different people and institutions made their own choices.
I'm not really competent to explain the whole development of the spelling or sound system of Gaelic from that point on, but ultimately the acute accents were dropped. They were still there in grammars and dictionaries from the early- to mid- 20th century (including mid-century
Teach Yourself Gaelic books), but they are missing from modern dictionaries. The process was haphazard, and in books from 40-50 years ago, you can find words written both ways in the same book. Even today, you will still see acute accents in things like song lyrics and proverbs from time to time (where you often also see old words which survive in Irish but are not used much in Gaelic now).
In some cases, a grave accent replaced the acute accent (Irish
álainn became Gaelic
àlainn), but in other cases the accent disappeared (compare Irish
tá and Gaelic
tha). In some cases, the disappearance of the accent makes sense, in that the vowels are not pronounced in the same way in the two languages. For example, Irish
tá ("taw") has a different vowel sound from Gaelic
tha ("haah"). It doesn't appear to me, though, as though there were systematic patterns followed. Just as one used to be able to find the same word with a grave or an acute accent in the same book, for some words there are now acceptable variants with or without an accent (but always a grave accent now, if there is an accent).