djwebb2021 wrote:
This is from An Músgraigheach, issue 6, Fóghmhar 1944, 21:
Quote:
Ag cainnt ar eagarthórí agus ar an eagarthóireacht a bhíos ... Déarfainn an rud céadna i dtaobh leabhar Dhiarmuid Uí Laoghaire dá gcreidinn é, ach táim-se ar do nós féin, tá nithe áirithe ná háiteochadh an saoghal orm. Seo ceann acu: go ndubhart ná go ndéarfadh Diarmuid “agus gurbh é tusa a bhí ag déanamh an chleamhnais” (An Bh. Bh., 247) ná gurab é fé ndeár an séimhiú ar ainmneacha bailtidheacha, e.g., “Ar Chnoc an Iúbhair” agus “thall ar Dhaingean na Saileach” (19).
Normally you find "ní duart ná go" = I didn't say but that=what I did say was that. (Dictionaries all list "but that" as the meaning of "ná go", but all uses of "but that" are confusing in modern English, and so these glosses are not very helpful.)
But here we find: go nduart ná go ndéarfadh Diarmaid X. I think this means the opposite of ní duart ná go, i.e. "I said that Diarmaid would not have said X". Can someone confirm the meaning of ná go after a positive verb. Dictionaries are of no help here.
I hardly understand this nested sentence, to be honest, so only a guess:
There is (nithe)
ná háiteochadh ... orm, containing a negation (ná = nach = which not)
Could the following part be perhaps a kind of an enumeration, enumerated by "ná" (
"nor", here maybe better
"or" in English)? It would be something totally different from "ná go" (CO: "nach")
So I'd translate: ... that I said
or that Diamaid would say ...
or that it is ...