I think it is all really down to the hours you are willing to invest in it. I was 'taught' Irish for 13 years in school. I left school with maybe a low A2 Level (A2 as in the Common European Framework of Reference). I obtained a B1 in Higher Level Leaving Cert Irish however, at that point I could barely understand basic conversations of native speakers and had no understanding of Irish phonology.
I have spent well over 1000 hours studying Irish as an adult learner (this consists of passive listening to RnaG while doing housework, driving etc, creating and reviewing thousands of flashcards of phrases in Anki, speaking to a native speaker weekly, reading Munster Irish books, listening to audiobooks and going to the odd Ciorcal Comhrá. I still would not regard myself as anywhere near fluent. I can have casual conversations with native speakers on a wide variety of topics. I understand typically 80-90% of what I hear on almost any topic on RnaG (if the speaker is from An Rinn, Múscraí or Corca Dhuibhne). However, I speak slowly and struggle occasionally to articulate myself. I make errors often but I usually can notice myself making them and self-correct. My passive vocabulary is far larger than my active one.
I really believe that to reach a C2 (CEFR) level with 'native-like pronunciation', it is not dissimilar to trying to become a master of a musical instrument. It will take many years maybe decades depending on how much time you are willing to invest on a regular basis. I definitely think some people are more linguistically gifted than others. However, the amount of information that you need to consume and digest to reach that level is truly enormous. I continue to work on my Irish almost everyday however, I accept that I probably won't feel truly comfortable in the language for another few years. Building automaticity in speaking (while maintaining good pronunciation) is one of the biggest hurdles (for me at least).
|