Quote:
Is it even properly systematic inside Gaoth Dobhair?
it is almost systematic in certain contexts, ie. between vowels in most cases, and at the end of words.
Quote:
I’ve certainly heard people in Gaoth Dobhair who only pronounced the slender r’s as y’s in certain contexts, but not in others; and oftentimes people who vacillated between r and y even in the same word … though I can’t say for sure if these people were perhaps from bordering areas.
I’ve always seen it as a sliding scale, where there were contexts where the replacement was more or less obligatory in Gaoth Dobhair (e.g., between an accented long (phonemically) non-front vowel and a schwa, as in Máire/gáire/náire/glóire/úire), and then there were contexts where it’s allowed and common, but not obligatory (e.g., between an accented short vowel and a non-schwa, as in deireadh/firín/goirid/mairim/cuireann).
So far I always heard y in deireadh, gairid ; never heard firín (I mean, never heard the word at all), but "fir" is pronounced "fiy". I never heard mairim nor cuireann with a y sound (but I heard "cuir" and "chuir" with a y, and even the verbal noun "cuir", instead of standard "cur). People may use a broad r in the conjugated forms of "cuir" as well (chur mé, curann sé, curfaidh mé...)
I never heard a y sound in "éirigh" and "éirí" (it would be "eeyee", so maybe it's because it would be a bit strange), nor in Éirinn or Éireann (while Éire is Éiye).
But what I wanted to say, is that in other dialects, pronuncing slender r (in the same cases ie. between vowels and at the end of words) as y is almost an exception. I heard máthaiy, athaiy, and a couple of words like that from people from Rannafast and Gort a' Choirce, but they do that much more rarely than Gweedore people.
An tOllamh D. O Baoill (from Gaoth Dobhair) told me that Gaoth Dobhair people tend to pronounce "normal slender r's" instead of the y-sounds, or even broad or "neutral" r's instead of these y when talking to people who aren't from Gaoth Dobhair (maybe they're afraid not to be understood otherwise...).