gaeliclearning wrote:
Séamus O'Neill wrote:
gaeliclearning wrote:
I've seen a thread on this board to this effect and I already reviewed it, but the OP of that thread was going for something a little different which is why I'm starting this thread.
Do you think that you could provide a link to this thread?
viewtopic.php?f=28&t=5504Actually it looks like Breandan proposed
Mise amháin but I would still be looking for a confirmation if that's accurate.
I would personally go with 'Mise Amháin'. I feel like the overall mysteriousness and ambiguousness of this phrase nicely overlaps with your original English phrase (i.e. 'I Alone' could mean many different things, but when explained has a more specific meaning, this is the same as with 'Mise Amháin') If you are wanting a single phrase that specifically encompasses the uses that you suggested, I unfortunately will not be able to be of much assistance.
As for the other suggestions posted on the thread you have:
'Mé Féin' literally means 'Myself', so I probably wouldn't choose this. I would say that the meaning of 'I alone' could only be made with an extended phrase with this one (i.e. Níl in ann é sin a dhéanamh ach mé féin = Nobody can do that but me)
'Liom Féin' - this suggestion was made by Bríd, who is a native speaker, so her input is of high value. This literally means 'With Myself'.
'Mé I M'Aonar' - this was suggested by Labhrás. Labhrás is well known on the forum for being highly knowledgeable on grammar, but I myself don't know how accurate this phrase would be. According to Teanglann, under
aonar in Ó Dónall's dictionary,
Tá mé i m'aonar means 'I am by myself', 'I am alone', which I don't think carries the meaning you're looking for.
I really hope this helps,
Séamus
Thanks so much for the help and analysis Séamus. I think the ambiguity of the first thread left me a bit concerned with going with any recommendations there without providing additional context for my own situation.
However, you and Breandán from that thread both seem to agree that for my use/context the best route is "Mise amháin". Can anyone offer a third confirmation? Thanks so much!